Key evidence an nummers
| Task in the review | Mean rate | Time warked oot for 1,000 wirds |
|---|---|---|
| Silent non-fiction | 238 WPM | Aboot 4 min 12 sec |
| Silent fiction | 260 WPM | Aboot 3 min 51 sec |
| Readin oot loud | 183 WPM | Aboot 5 min 28 sec |
The oral estimate wis taen fae 77 studies and 5,965 pairticipants. The silent and oral groups differ in texts, instructions and pairticipants, sae takkin 183 awa fae 238 disnae prove that ilk reader gains 55 WPM by readin silently. Nor dae group averages set a guid speakin voice, a fluency diagnosis or a performance target. Brysbaert, 2019
Speakkin adds anither ootput task
Readin oot loud coordinates seein wirds, processin language and speakin. Silent readin still processes language, but disnae hae tae bide for ilk wird tae be physically spoken. Reviews o ee-muivements describe hoo visual samplin and language processin wirk thegither; naither task is juist muivin the een alang a line. Rayner, 1998 CLIFTON et al., 2015
This difference disnae mean that silent readin has nae sound-relatit representations. The speed-readin review explains why stoppin inner speech isnae a proven general wey tae get extremely fast comprehension. No hearable speech and nae phonological processin are twa different claims. Rayner et al., 2016
Whilk wey gies better comprehension?
The twa rate averages cannae answer that question by theirsels. Comprehension depends on the material, purpose and reader. An experiment on preventin rereadin shaws that gaun back tae wirds can help wi understandin; a strict instruction tae keep up a fast pace micht cut oot useful processin time in baith modes. Schotter et al., 2014
Whit affects it?
Why age and language change the comparison
The review finds different rates for bairns, aulder adults and second-language readers. Wird ken and experience wi a language affect recognition, and research on second languages shaws that frequency effects depend on a reader's experience wi ilk language. Sae a learner's oral and silent rates needna differ in the same wey as the pooled averages for adult English. Brysbaert, 2019 Whitford et al., 2012
Recognisin vocabulary isna the same as speakin fluently. Estimates o wirds kent depend on the unit used for coontin, while readin coverage depends on the wirds in the particular text. Thir are reasons no tae yais ae oral WPM figure as a general verdict on language skill. Brysbaert et al., 2016 Nation, 2006
Whit is realistic tae practise?
Chuse a wey that suits the task: presentin oot loud and readin for yer ain unnerstaunin use owerlapin but sindry skills. Compare like material wi like material and check yer comprehension. The readin reviews support interpretin results for the task at haund, no a universal advice that awbodie should aye read in ae wey. Brysbaert, 2019 Rayner et al., 2016
For an informal comparison, uise unfamiliar passages o similar difficulty and dinna read the same passage oot loud richt efter readin it silently. Familiarity wad muddle the comparison. Tak the result as an observation aboot thae passages, no a validated test o yer basic intelligence or a promise aboot aw buik. CLIFTON et al., 2015 Rayner, 1998
Gin a rate chynges, be clear aboot whit it means: quicker readin wi puirer unnerstaunin is a different result fae quicker readin wi the same unnerstaunin. A speed nummer alane cannae tell the twa apairt. Rayner et al., 2016 Schotter et al., 2014
Gie the related free test a try
Readin speed test
Try the readin speed test as a silent-readin task and uise its comprehension questions. It disnae measure fluency at readin oot loud. Keep ony separate timing for readin oot loud marked as a different task.
Common questions
Is readin oot loud meant tae be 183 WPM?
That is a pooled average, no a requirement. The text, instructions, pairticipants' traits and purpose aa affect the result. Brysbaert, 2019
Does silent readin dae awa wi inner speech?
Naw. The speed-readin review distinguishes inner speech that's pairt o language processin fae physically speakin ilk wird oot loud. Rayner et al., 2016
Can a silent test assess ma speakin ability?
It cannae establish that fae readin rate alane. Speakkin oot loud adds demands that a silent completion time disnae measure. CLIFTON et al., 2015
Sources
- Brysbaert (2019). Hou mony wirds dae we read in a meenit? A review and meta-analysis o readin rate.
- Rayner et al. (2016). Sae Mony Things tae Read, Sae Little Time.
- Rayner (1998). Ee-muivements in readin and information processin: 20 years o research..
- CLIFTON et al. (2015). Ee-muivements in readin and information processin: Keith Rayner's 40 year legacy.
- Whitford et al. (2012). Second-language experience chynges first- and second-language wird frequency effects: Evidence fae ee-muivement measures o readin natural paragraphs.
- Nation (2006). Hou muckle vocabulary is needed for readin and listenin?.
- Schotter et al. (2014). Dinna Believe Whit Ye Read (Ae Time Alane).
- Brysbaert et al. (2016). Hou Mony Wirds Dae We Ken? Practical Estimates o Vocabulary Size Dependin on Wird Definition, Degree o Language Input and the Pairticipant's Age.
Cite this page: Whit for is readin silently quicker nor readin oot loud?. Helibrain. 2026. https://helibrain.com/sco/answers/reading-aloud-vs-silent-reading. CC BY 4.0.
← Explore mair answers